The Media and the Responsibility of the Consumer

My relationship to the media is a rather convoluted one. I was born in the early 2000s as the youngest of four children, my siblings were born six, eight and ten years prior. My mom was 39 and my dad was 41 when I was born. I give this information as a preface as I believe that it inherently has affected the way I view and interact with the media.

Facebook was launched before I was born, Twitter before I was two and Instagram before I was ten. Yet as the youngest I watched my siblings start to interact and engage with these new media platforms and I watched my parents struggle to keep up with this new wave and all that it entailed.

In middle school when most other of my peers were joining these platforms I was not allowed to partake. This became a bit of a struggle for me since most trends I did not know or did not understand, I felt as though I was being left behind in a way.

While now, in retrospect, I can much better grasp my parents’ wariness in allowing me to join my peers, as these sites tapped into unrestricted reaches of the internet. Yet I still do find myself questioning their decision and thinking that they perhaps let fear guide them a little too much in the matter. Furthermore, I find myself wondering what I would have done in their place.

Since I was born on somewhat of a precipice of the media revolution I had classes in which so-called “media literacy” was discussed. In the discussions I have had on this topic in school and with people much older than I, it has always had a sense of fear and danger tinted within it. 

Now as an adult I find these conversations often lack the depth that I think they require. Yes, the media has changed, and  drastically at that, with new dangers being introduced. To not acknowledge that would be, on my part, folly but in all that danger, great things have come out of this revolution. Platforms are given to people who otherwise would be voiceless. And yes, platforms have been given to people who should probably have a quieter voice. But honestly these platforms are created by those who are engaging so really what we need to consider when talking about “media literacy” is the power of the individual masses. 

Before diving into the bulk of this topic, I like to define things when beginning to discuss them to avoid unnecessary disputes/semantics. With that respect I would be transparent about the definition of “media literacy”. “Media Literacy”, which I have taken from National Association of Media Literacy Educators is: “The ability to access, analyze, evaluate, create and act using all forms of communication”.

Since this media revolution we have increased the access to information exponentially and with that not all information we are exposed to is indeed factual yet in our exposure it can directly and indirectly, consciously and unconsciously affect us. In a PBS crash course video they say “The creator’s experiences and environment affect everything they create. Their messages are filled with tons of baggage. And we consumers have our own baggage, too, which determines how we react to and interpret messages.”. I like this quote because it places responsibility on both the media and the consumers acknowledging that neither are impartial. This is a keystone piece in understanding media and gaining literacy.

In preparation for this post I was introduced to British sociologist Stuart Hall and his theory of encoding and decoding. This theory pushed back on the current beliefs of the time that media messages’ meaning remained unchanging throughout the process of communication (Mambrol, 2020). Hall instead argued meaning cannot be fixed by the sender despite all their attempts to do so. In a lecture Hall, referring to the attempt of fixing meaning, says: “what we are looking at is a practice, which is always going to be subverted; and, you know, the purpose of power, when it intervenes in language, is precisely to absolutely fix” he goes on to say that this practice is what “ideology” is attempting to do, fix certain meanings onto people, events and other such things saying “a relationship between the image and a powerful definition of it to become naturalized so that that is the only meaning it can possibly carry…Whenever you see that event, you will assume it has that political consequence.”

Thus I come back to what I believe is a keystone piece in understanding media and gaining literacy; we, the audience, have to fully acknowledge that neither we nor the media we are consuming is unbiased. 

So it is then on us to recognize what media we are accessing. What messages is it sending us? Who is delivering these messages? How are their opinions coloring those messages? And then in turn when we create and add to the media of our world we must acknowledge the responsibility we in turn carry.

References

National Association for Media Literacy Education. (n.d.). Media Literacy Defined. NAMLE. https://namle.org/resources/media-literacy-defined/

Mambrol, N. (2020, November 7). Analysis of Stuart Hall’s Encoding/Decoding. Literary Theory and Criticism. https://literariness.org/2020/11/07/analysis-of-stuart-halls-encoding-decoding/#google_vignette

Bishop, K. (2021, November 30). Representation and the Media by Stuart Hall. http://Www.youtube.com. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84depWskwu0

6 responses to “The Media and the Responsibility of the Consumer”

  1. Hi Grace,

    I enjoyed reading your perspective because I had a similar experience growing up during the rise of social media. Your point about media literacy often being discussed through a lens of fear was especially interesting. I also liked your discussion of Stuart Hall’s encoding and decoding theory because it highlights how people can interpret the same message in completely different ways. Your conclusion was strong, especially the idea that both media creators and audiences share responsibility for the messages being communicated and consumed.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I love this post! I was also born in the early 2000’s but as the oldest, I didn’t have siblings to watch navigate the rise of social media and the internet. My parents were also very wary about social media, and I was not allowed much growing up. “Yet I still do find myself questioning their decision and thinking that they perhaps let fear guide them a little too much in the matter. Furthermore, I find myself wondering what I would have done in their place.” is very well written and explains the conflicted feelings very well. I also agree with the part about conversations about media literacy lacking depth. There are so many layers to the internet and media, and I also feel there is a lot lacking in the typical discussions. I can’t agree more with this part, “Thus I come back to what I believe is a keystone piece in understanding media and gaining literacy; we, the audience, have to fully acknowledge that neither we nor the media we are consuming is unbiased.” How we interpret and understand media is up to us, despite the messages encoded. Love the post! Very well written!!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Dude, my mom was the same. I legit didnt have a phone until I was 14 ( didnt have cellular data) then finally got my official phone when I was 16. My mom ( who is now 40) didnt want me to become like the other kids she saw, stuck to their devices, not going outside, not socializing, wrapped up in views that media fed them. I felt like I was also behind. I remember being in middle school seeing someone getting the new iPhone and being like ” I want to see those things too”. In perspective now, it made me realize that not having a device allowed me to have a childhood of using your imagination, finding the good in boredom ( which led to exploration). Kids now are already in social media being fed these targeted views, these representation that make them feel ‘I have to have/do this’.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Good job, Finn’s mom! I have grandkids with devices and other grandkids who haven’t had devices. Guess which group can play forever in the yard making up stories about bugs and flowers?

      Like

  4. Hi Grace, I really liked your point about how media literacy is usually taught with a lot of fear around it. I feel like people focus so much on the dangers of social media that they forget about the opportunities it creates too. Your experience growing up watching your siblings use social media while not being allowed to have it yourself was also interesting because it gives a different perspective than most people our age. I enjoyed reading your blog, thanks for sharing!

    Like

  5. I liked how you framed media literacy as a shared responsibility between creators and consumers rather than just something to fear. Your use of Stuart Hall’s encoding/decoding theory gave the post a strong foundation, and your personal experiences helped make the discussion feel thoughtful, grounded, and relevant.

    Like

Leave a comment